Magic + Loss

Magic + Loss

There's nothing ironic about Payton Gendron

Virginia Heffernan's avatar
Virginia Heffernan
May 18, 2022
∙ Paid
Green infinity symbol, with "chan" underneath in black lowercase sans serif text
Former 8chan logo.

Payton Gendron, the only suspect in the Buffalo mass murder, identifies explicitly as a white supremacist fascist. He adds that he has neo-Nazi beliefs.

After his arrest, Gendron reportedly told police he found Black people contemptible and murdered them for that reason.

Cops also say Gendron wrote a manifesto that advances the claim that treacherous elites are hellbent on expanding immigration and suppressing white birth rates. They want to make sure that Black, Jewish, Brown and Muslim people overpower White Christians. 

(Gendron's claim is known as "replacement theory." The phrase is misleading. A theory is an abstract idea, value-neutral and designed to be tested. His claim is a garden-variety lie.)

You'd think that Gendron's self-description—that he's a racist with racist reasoning—would close the case on the question of motive here. But some journalists, charged with extending the story on tight deadlines, have rejected the murderer's own account of his motives and reasons. They offer instead a cracked version of economic determinism that has about as much bearing on reality as the "great replacement." 

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Virginia Heffernan.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Virginia Heffernan · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture