Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Don Frazier's avatar

I've known a lot of socialists in NYC. There was the guy who photobombed Columbia's ur-protest in 1968 and went on to perform in Yayoi Kusama's love-ins. There was the airline executive who underwrote one of the first impactful tenant groups in the Village, and the woman who set up a chain of local food coops. I helped lead foraging expeditions into perfectly good buildings awaiting demolition, in defiance of property rights and the law.

A diverse crowd. But they had two things in common. Impeccable socialist credentials, and they liked to make a buck.

My observation is that many, many New Yorkers like to make a buck. Not just the industrial-grade exploiters in finance and development, but normal people too. My own sharecropper grandma came up from the Delta with a third-grade education and a passel of illiterate relations, and she really liked to make a buck and got good at it.

Your movement is capturing a lot of attention just now. But I see no messaging at all that says anything nice about wanting to make a buck. Instead it's mainly the rhetoric of torches and pitchforks. I've even heard Franz Fanon invoked, and with no sense of irony at all.

All of you who see great things in this, as an honorary New Yorker who left years ago, I defer. But you could do a lot worse than making it clear that you, too, envision a kinder, gentler NYC that's still amenable to making a buck.

Expand full comment
Eberhard Tarpening's avatar

Brianna, you devil. Sign me up for Hot Commie Summer.

Expand full comment

No posts